An Open Letter to J.Crew (@JCrew_Insider): What Has Become of Your Brand?

Dear J.Crew,

You seem to be having an identity crisis.  I can sense deep turmoil about who you are and what your brand is. 

As a long time J.Crew loyalist who is extremely close to putting you out to pasture – as I did the Gap many years ago – I would like to help you remember who you are.

You are a brand that can be counted on for classic, breezy, beautiful pieces…pieces that deliver classic lines with an occasional sexy flair…pieces that ultimately communicate American chic. 

Need help conjuring your brand??  Imagine the Kennedy’s vacationing in Hyannis Port, think of scenes from The Talented Mr Ripley – yes, a psychopath may have been slowly unraveling their lives but they were impeccably dressed.

In case you have lost yourself in the NYC hype (trust that I love NYC, I was a resident for some time).  In case you have listened too long to the “in crowd” telling you that you have to be funkier and crazier and more out there – be yourself. 

This is who you are – This is why stylish women across the country have counted on you for decades.   

THIS IS WHO YOU ARE NOT – Yet these sloppily thrown together styles make up the large majority of the March 2011 catalogue.  AND this lazy and insulting styling has been going on for quite some time.  I can no longer stand by with the hopes that things will get better. 

I have to let you know how unacceptable these looks are.

What’s wrong with these looks you ask?

Really???  Baggy, unflattering and ill-fitted shorts, held up with an un-impressive belt, topped off with a dull gray sweater with a doily overlay – and the doily sweater costs $198.  How is this outfit classic?  Where’s the structure and tailored look that was a J.Crew trademark?

Am I on punked???  What woman with an ounce of fashion sense is going to pair these blue shorts covered in “iridescent paillettes” with an olive military jacket…and the espadrilles just add insult to injury.  Can these shorts be done right – absolutely…with the right top, a clutch and an appropriate shoe one might possibly “win”…but this is a lose-lose scenario.

If ANYONE at J.Crew reads this – please note that this picture is proof positive that you are WAYYYYY off brand.  Someone is taking themselves a bit too seriously here AND shame on the people in the creative meeting that didn’t shoot this look down.  Really???  A HORRIBLE looking paisley shirt, topped with an army green sequin cami, finished off with an out of place tweed jacket and paired with an extremely dingy looking pair of shorts – “tap-tap, is this thing on?”

Someone at J.Crew has obviously taken to rolling up orange socks and smoking them like hashish.  Really???  Sandals with Socks??? and what statement is the dull and un-inspiring outfit making.  This model has on baggy jean shorts and a CROCHET sweater.  Just stop it.

#FAIL.  These “wool portia pants” are so un-flattering it hurts.  Since when would a loyal J.Crew shopper want a pair of pants that purposely fit her baggy in the waist? – or as you say “Relaxed through hip and thigh.”  And to have the audacity to pair these ill-fitting pants with an ill-fitting gray sweater – THIS DOES NOT MAKE SENSE.  It is insulting.

This isn’t a total miss – the sequined sweater paired with the jean shirt underneath are on message with the J.Crew that I remember but again with these ridiculous shorts.  Someone needs to answer for these shorts.  They are anti-style.  The woman that adopts these shorts into her wardrobe DOES NOT SHOP AT J.CREW.

AND this outfit.  I won’t even touch the shoe and book bag combination…but, on what planet does the J.Crew woman pair a hoodie – that so clearly mimics an athletic hoodie – with a blazer???  I don’t know what’s worse the clearly inappropriate pairing of the athletic hoodie and blazer or the lifeless “toffee” colored skirt that looks like it’s hard enough to scratch your face.

J.Crew please know that my disgust is coming from a place of love.  I have relied on your brand for more than a decade to deliver the classic, elegant, and sometimes edgy pieces that were the staples of my wardrobe.

You seem to be making a decision to turn your back on the classic brand that you established, trading it for some confused, non-stylish hipster version of the brand you think that people want.  But here is a wake up call – THE J.CREW WOMAN DOES NOT LIKE THE NON-STYLE “STYLE” THAT YOU’VE RECENTLY ADOPTED.

There is a right and a wrong way to introduce “funk” into the classic J.Crew style – and you’ve got it wrong.

Your loyal customers will soon turn their backs on you if you don’t quickly get the message and bring back the Charlotte York-esque styling that is your brand’s trade mark.  Once you come back to center and begin to deliver what people want, then let’s sit down at the table and talk about smart ways to add in funky accents. 

I am certain that you are not being edgy with the above mash-ups – you are being tone deaf irresponsible stewards of your brand.

Best of luck.  If i can help in any way please let me know.

— Loyal J.Crew customer, trying to hang in there for better, smarter designs.

Sign the “Classic Campaign: Bring Back J.Crew’s Classic & Iconic Design” petition


One thought on “An Open Letter to J.Crew (@JCrew_Insider): What Has Become of Your Brand?

  1. I understand your disappointment with J crew as of late, due to their changes in regards to styling. But I wouldn’t see this transition as a bad one. Their just evolving their look and expanding their demographic. Most of the pieces found decades ago are still available, their just offering more and showcasing it in a modern way.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s